How we warned people about scareware in Edge - strongly enough to protect them, without amplifying fear.
Scareware is designed to exploit fear, urgency and confusion to coerce users into unsafe actions. In a browser, poor interventions can fail to protect users or damage trust.
This case study brings together multiple trust and safety surfaces I worked on across Edge, including Scareware Blocker, Browser Essentials security flows, threat messaging, and related error and recovery states.
I was responsible for the UX design of key scareware and security intervention flows, with a focus on messaging, severity calibration and recovery paths. I worked closely with PMs, engineers and security stakeholders to balance user protection, false positives and trust. This included:

The central challenge was deciding when to intervene, how strongly, and how to help users recover safely - without amplifying fear.
Under-warning
Users fall victim to scams
Over-warning
Users stop trusting the browser
Ambiguous warnings
Panic and unsafe decisions

We already had some empty state and error page warnings, but they didn’t feel aligned. I was conscious of respecting those pages to retain trust - and it was also a chance to address them.
Not all threats deserve the same visual weight. I needed to convey a potential risk rather than a hard block, but something more important than an informational warning like a 404 error.

Finding messaging that reduced panic and avoided alarmist language was important. The AI could sometimes raise false positives, so I left the final choice to the user on whether to proceed.
User testing showed it helped most to keep a screenshot of the destination site on screen, so people could make a more informed decision. Language was intentionally designed to slow users down rather than escalate urgency.
Design decisions were shaped by security accuracy limits and legal review, which constrained both language and interaction patterns.

Scareware Blocker has been covered in several press releases since launch, and it’s great to read about how it’s helping users. This feature matters a lot to me, because it helps vulnerable people stay away from scams.
Check out the Microsoft Blog article on Scareware